An article released on March 23 in the Archives of Internal Medicine reveals that, surprise, Americans eat too much meat. We’ve heard all of that before. The surprising thing was that this article also found that those consuming white meat had a decreased risk of both total mortality and cancer mortality. White meat included chicken, turkey and fish, as well as poultry cold cuts, canned tuna and low-fat sausages and hot dogs made from poultry.
Over the 10 year follow-up period from 1995 to 2005, there were 47,976 male deaths and 23,276 female deaths. The scientists found that individuals in the highest group of red meat intake tended to consume a slightly lower amount of white meat but a higher amount of processed meat compared with those in the lowest group.
There are some flaws in the study. Generally, those who eat more red meat also tend to be less concerned about health already (overweight, low activity), so it’s hard to say if it’s the meat or the lifestyle that causes the increased in mortality. On the other hand, several other studies have linked high red meat consumption with high levels of cancer. However, the cooking process contributes to the carcinogen content of some meats, and that was not taken into account in this study.
How Much Is Too Much?
According to this study, based on a 2000 calorie/day diet, men eating 4.8 ounces (136.2 grams) of red meat daily had a 31% increased risk of mortality over a given decade than men that consumed just 0.7 ounces (18.6 grams). Women eating 4.6 ounces (131.8 grams) of red meat daily had a 36% increased risk of mortality over a given decade than women who consumed just 0.6 ounces (18.2 grams).
The study group recommends limiting red meat to 500 grams, or 18 ounces per week, to reduce the risk of cancer.
What Can We Do?
The more studies that come out on the “Western Diet,” “The Medittarian Diet,” “The French Paradox” or anything to do with food, the more we see that “excess” is the bad thing, and not one food. Even though the study may be a little flawed, that message is not.
We live in a country where portions get bigger and bigger, and so do people.
Pharmacists have a unique role in healthcare because we see most patients at least once a month. They only see their physcians every few months (sometimes only twice a year). While most patients know that “excess” is bad, most patients don’t understand what excess is.
Too often, we tell patients, “Don’t eat [food].” but we rarely say, “You can eat…” It’s important for us to counsel interested patients not only on what to avoid, but what to eat. Just for comparison purposes, 1.5 ounces of meat is about two slices of lunch meat. Patients should get less than 3 ounces of red meat everyday.
The Heart and Stroke Foundation recommends selecting lean meat and alternatives, trimming visible fat from meats, removing skin from poultry and using cooking methods such as roasting, baking or poaching that require little or no added fat.
What About Grass Fed Beef?
Depends on who you ask! Many say that grass fed beef is higher in omega-3 fatty acids and lower in omega-6 fatty acids, that corn-fed beef. It’s also supposed to be high in micronutrients and vitamins, and low in saturated fat. The verdict is still out on its benefits (or detriment) to your health, so I would still recommend moderation. Gourmet had a nice editorial on this article comparing grass vs. corn-fed animals, that talks about some of the problems with corn-fed animals.
You often hear people who raise grass-fed beef touting that the switch from grass-fed to corn-fed animals was the start of the obesity epidemic. However, around the time of that switch was when portion sizes started to increase. You be the judge on which was more to blame.
Bottom Line
Portion control and exercise are still the most important aspects of diet, rather you eat red meat or not. There are such things as fat, unhealthy vegetarians, and healthy carnivores.
Grass-fed beef may be healthier, but it doesn’t give you free reign to eat all you want. I think sometimes people hear something is lower fat or “healthy” and think that means they can eat all they want. The same goes with white meat. It was found to be healthy, but that does not mean you can eat a whole chicken in one setting. A 4 oz portion of meat is about the size of deck of cards.
Portion control is, in my opinion, still the most important thing for us all to understand.